Press Release - MSC urged to align its operations with international environmental and labour rights standards and stop dumping its toxic waste on South Asian beaches

Press Release – MSC urged to align its operations with international environmental and labour rights standards and stop dumping its toxic waste on South Asian beaches

Published in December 02nd, 2024

One of the world's largest container shipping companies, Mediterranean Shipping Company (MSC), is again under the spotlight for its substandard and hazardous dismantling of obsolete vessels on tidal beaches in South Asia. While the company has repeatedly faced criticism for breaching international environmental and labour rights standards, it has so far not shown any willingness to improve its practices.

Claiming to be committed to sustainable operations, MSC has received several awards including the Greenest Ship Owner of the Year at the 2018 Green Shipping Summit in Amsterdam. Yet, the Swiss shipping giant has over the last fifteen years sold more than 100 end-of-life vessels for dirty and dangerous scrapping on South Asian beaches. In the last six months only, MSC scrapped 9 ships on the beach of Alang in India - 27 in the last two years, including the MSC FLORIANA and MSC GIOVANNA. These vessels left respectively from Spanish and Turkish waters in direct violation of European and international laws prohibiting the export of hazardous waste from OECD to non-OECD countries.

"Dumping toxic ships on tidal beaches is both environmentally destructive and exploitative of poorly-paid and unprotected workers. It constitutes a serious criminal offence, as highlighted by recent rulings in the EU (1). We have therefore alerted relevant authorities of MSC’s blatant breach of environmental law governing international waste trade, and are following up to see what action can be taken."

Ingvild Jenssen - Executive Director and Founder - NGO Shipbreaking Platform

MSC's poor management of its end-of-life assets is particularly deplorable given its financial strength. The company, with a staggering $86 billion turnover in 2022, is expanding rapidly, with an estimated capacity soon matching the combined fleets of competitors Maersk and Hapag-Lloyd. However, despite the financial capacity to sustainably recycle their end-of-life fleet, MSC seemingly prefers to accumulate profits by exposing workers, vulnerable coastal communities and sensitive ecosystems to harm. Indeed, with prices reaching up to $500 per Light Displacement Tonnage (LDT) for scrapping on the beaches of South Asia, MSC can earn up to three times more compared to recycling its assets in EU-approved facilities.

By contrast, earlier this year, MSC UK launched the Waste Shipment Intelligence Service in collaboration with the UK Environmental Agency, aiming to curb the illegal trade of waste on-board its vessels. In August this year, MSC also returned 40 containers of hazardous waste that had been illegally exported on-board two A.P. Moller-Maersk’s A/S - another company that dumps its end-of-life vessels on South Asian beaches - chartered ships from Albania.

"Whilst we applaud MSC for its commitment to assist authorities in combatting illegal waste trade, it is ironic, even hypocritical, that MSC does this all whilst continuing to dump its own toxic waste on beaches in South Asia. We urge MSC to reform its ship recycling policy to ensure that its end-of-life vessels are disposed of in line with the highest safety and environmental standards."

Ingvild Jenssen - Executive Director and Founder - NGO Shipbreaking Platform

Currently, MSC’s recycling policy remains weak, relying solely on the Hong Kong Convention (HKC), a framework widely criticised for failing to ban beaching and properly manage hazardous waste downstream. Also, while the company claims to audit scrapping yards, it provides no transparency on the process or results. Independent audits have already found major flaws in yards that claim HKC compliance, particularly in South Asia, and that are used by MSC.

MSC's top management also came under scrutiny from Swiss media for its aggressive lobbying efforts directed at the Swiss Federal Tax Administration (FTA). The aim was to introduce an exceptionally favourable tonnage tax regime in Switzerland, which could have resulted in virtually zero taxation for the company. According to detailed reports from Reflekt, MSC succeeded in incorporating several items from its "wish list” into the draft bill of the Swiss tonnage tax regime, including the removal of stringent requirements related to flag states and labour rights compliance. However, the National Council rejected the draft proposal in May 2024.

Repeated attempts by the Platform to engage with MSC’s sustainability team on their recycling policy have gone unanswered. As MSC continues to turn a blind eye to the irreversible damage caused by the poor end-of-life management of its fleet, and lobbies for lowering compliance with international labour rights, there is growing global emphasis on both environmental sustainability and corporate accountability. Companies are expected to align their operations with not only their stated values, but also the law. The Platform remains committed to assisting companies achieve this, including by means of actively supporting technological innovation and meaningful advancements in the ship recycling sector to create capacity for sustainable ship recycling.

MSC’s competitor CMA-CGM is already exploring how to boost sustainable ship recycling in Europe following a commitment in 2022 to not transport plastic waste on-board its vessels. Now is the time for MSC to show whether or not they are truly committed to sustainability throughout their entire operational chain.

NOTE

(1) Several high-profile legal proceedings, such as those surrounding the Harrier case, are drawing attention to persistent violations of EU laws by ship owners attempting to circumvent regulations. Criminal investigations underway in multiple EU nations, including Germany, reflect a growing international commitment to holding offenders accountable and strengthening regulatory enforcement to address environmental and labor hazards associated with unlawful shipbreaking.

Brussels, Feb 01st 2024

Press Release – Platform publishes list of ships dismantled worldwide in 2023

In 2023, 325 large tankers, bulkers, floating platforms, cargo- and passenger ships ended up for dirty and dangerous breaking on beaches in Bangladesh, India and Pakistan.

Chittagong/Brussels, May 09th 2016

Platform News – Shooting and fatal accidents at Kabir shipbreaking: Belgian ship owner CMB, Greek Kanellakis Group and Standard Chartered linked

Standard Chartered Bank, Belgian ship owner CMB / Bocimar as well as the Greek Kanellakis Group are linked to Kabir Steel, a Bangladeshi shipbreaking yard and re-rolling… Read More

Brussels, Oct 20th 2016

Press Release – European industry, trade unions and NGOs jointly support the EESC’s call for a financial incentive to enhance sustainable ship recycling

Today, the European Economic and Social Committee (EESC) adopted an own initiative opinion that calls on the European Commission to introduce an incentive that will “eliminate the… Read More

Taiwan, Jun 22nd 2020

Platform News – Platform’s member BELA awarded the 2020 Tang Prize

Bangladesh Environmental Lawyers Association has been awarded the prestigious 2020 Tang Prize in Rule of Law.

MORE NEWS

Brussels, Jan 31st 2023

Press Release – Brazil set to violate three international environmental treaties in sinking PCB-laden aircraft carrier in the Atlantic

Environmentalists denounce Brazilian Navy for ‘criminal negligence’.

British Columbia, May 02nd 2023

Press Release – Local residents rally against shipbreaking operation in Union Bay, British Columbia

Local residents marched last Sunday at Union Bay to protest against the dirty and dangerous scrapping operations carried out in the area by Deep Water Recovery Ltd (DWR).

Chittagong, May 15th 2019

Press Release – Major explosion at Bangladesh shipbreaking yard kills two workers and severely injures five

A fire broke out on board the Malaysian-owned vessel BUNGA KELANA 4, beached at Mahinur Ship Breaking yard.

Brussels/Chittagong, Dec 07th 2017

Press Release – NGOs and trade unions denounce certification issued to PHP yard by classification society RINA

In October, the PHP Family (Peace Happiness and Prosperity) shipbreaking yard received a Statement of Compliance with the Hong Kong Convention [1] by the Italian classification society… Read More